Skip to main content

That Tetchy, Touchy, Testy Topic – Book Reviews


It has come to my attention that it is time to update readers and writers on my book review process... So please, find a comfy chair... because this might take more than a moment.

There are several ways to look at book reviews.

From a historical perspective book reviews were most respected when published, or blurbed by literary professionals, either inside literary publications or somewhere in/on the book (cover) itself. Almost every writer, if not e-v-e-r-y single writer, kowtowed to have a lit maven of the Boston Globe, you-name-the-best-selling-author merit, praise his or her book.

Today, while this continues to be a mainstream value, the over zealousness of getting ‘honest-reliable’ book reviews has tapered the appeal for readers primarily, and some authors as well.

Without spelling out the list of remarks that dispute the authenticity of reviews, I am one of the authors who early on shunned seeking reviews. Of course, it excited me to hear/read what a reader had to say about one of my books, but I can count on one hand, and maybe one or two fingers on the other hand, how many times a reader has taken time to review one of my books.

Harriet Koskoff, Midwest Reviews, Harriet Klausner, and RAWSISTAZ™ reviewers floored me to read what they thought of my stories. Absolutely and wholly floored me because even though I sent my book(s) to these individuals, I did not expect to hear anything back.  So, for them to not only review my book without NO cajoling, and to share thoughts and words that expressed my work contained literary merit, swelled my head (and you’ll have to use your imagination to picture) how BIG!

As a reader, a writer, and book reviewer this transparent reviewing process is invaluable to the book industry.

We---and we meaning those of us that value the book industry---want to build a trust among readers. We want readers to trust that what we write about a book is true to our perception of what we read.

We, and perhaps I’ll leave this one at solely I, want to build a trust among writers and authors as well. Regardless of what I write about a book, I want authors to trust that I actually read their book and it really resonated with me. I want them to feel the way I did when Harriet Koskoff, Midwest Reviews, Harriet Klausner, and RAWSISTAZ™ reviewers reviewed my books.

Generally, I’ll invest at least a sentence to all books I’ve read on Goodreads. Most of those that really resonate with me I’ll post on my review blog. And a few select reviews I post to Amazon.

At all costs I steer clear from turning potential readers away from reading. I’m not giving no reader the opportunity to say, “yeah, I think you’re right. I won’t read that book.”

Reading Between the Lines: Inspire writers to grow reader after reader after reader after reader...

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A Rumor About One Race

It’s a funny thing, how some things you hear stay with you in that sixth sense sort of way, as if the information will serve some future purpose.

True Story. I was in elementary school when a teacher got to talking about three true races—Caucasian, Mongoloid, and Negroid, and how one day there would be One Race. For a placeholder I attended Philadelphia (PA) Public Schools, K-straight thru-12 (99.98% black student population) where there was always ‘that’ teacher who would put aside a textbook to impart ‘move to the edge of your seat’ information... something I later figured out would take “dynamic positioning” to find its originating source. I even think the teacher may have said we wouldn’t find this information written anywhere.

At any rate, I’m all kinds of fuzzy about how the original three races came to be, but recall 3rd grade hands going up in the air asking why this and how that and what about this, and then somebody saying, “unt un... my mother said...”

Naturally I was intr…

When Opinions Cross the Line

Two literary topographies brought this historical commentary together; a social media Headline asserting some books are irrelevant, and Stacey Dash’s memoir, ‘There Goes My Social Life’. (My other thoughts here).

I didn't pause long enough to so much as note the social media headline, but did pause after catching wind of Stacey Dash's outspoken stance on supporting American businessman and Republican politician, Mitt Romney. Stacey is an American Actress notable for her role in the film CluelessSIGH—I’ve never seen Clueless, but have seen this actress in other films... which was what inspired me to want to read her memoir. Being a Big Picture thinker, I couldn't make heads or tails out of the hoopla behind her outspoken political views.

My great-great grandfather, born in America in the mid 1800’s, was a Republican. Per my father, historically the American working class primarily voted Republican, though he, and then me, marveled about my great-great grandfather's r…

What Makes a Book Feel Good? ...A Top 10 List

When you ...as it’s said... live and learn, you learn LOVE comes in stages. So far, I’ve come across three stages of love. Puppy Love. Hormonal Love. And the ultimate love. Unconditional Love.

Lo and behold albeit, after finally getting around to reading Roy Blount’s memoir, “Be Sweet” (a memoirist who has at least twenty some years on me), I got to reading him summarizing unconditional love as ‘just an expression’ ..."like any other two words." Now, because his memoir is largely satirical, and given the title, on top of knowing better to think I know more than my elders (haha), it was hard to tell whether to take the definition seriously or facetiously. Whichever the case, as of today I define unconditional love without conditions. Unlike puppy love, built largely on a giddy childish infatuation superficially marveling over things or people, or that hormonal love responding to the cyclones and ebbs moving our hormones in this invisible like cylinder, there are no ifs, ands…